Many of you know that I harbor some strong political views. I avoid posting my thoughts on what goes on inside the Beltway - mostly for fear of igniting powderkegs that promise to create more heat and noise than light.
But this is an issue of Justice.
Cyrus Kar, an American father, documentary filmmaker, and former Navy SEAL was detained for two months in an American-run Iraqi prison and suffered abysmal treatment - even after being cleared by the FBI of any wrongdoing.
From CNN:
Kar said that while he was imprisoned he was at various times hooded and threatened, taunted and insulted by U.S. soldiers. One soldier slammed Kar’s head into a concrete wall, the suit said.
He’s now suing Donald Rumsfeld and other top military officials in what is the first civil case brought to the Supreme Court regarding detention policies.
I love America. I thank God that we have a military composed of individuals who have placed themselves under the authority of the government in order to serve the rest of us. But in cases such as this (and I expect that this is far from being an isolated incident), I question some of our soldiers. And I question those who hand out the orders.
It hurts to call to account these people whom we’re supposed to be able to trust and respect. But at the moment, they’re our representatives to the rest of the world (though I wonder about the value of this, too). Sometimes I fear that our chief export may become a xenophobic attitude dressed in camouflage. The trouble is, these xenophobic attitudes have guns.
By no means do I wish to imply that all of our fine soldiers harbor these attitudes. My point is that if we wish to project authority as a foreign power, it is of utmost importance that we do so justly.
Cy is from Los Angeles. He’s an American citizen - and from the looks of it, quite a productive one (it takes guts to make a documentary in Iraq). He was cleared of charges. And he was thrown against a concrete wall by his fellow citizens.
Have a look at what the Pentagon had to say about this incident:
“This case highlights the effectiveness of our detainee review process,” spokesman Air Force Brig. Gen. Don Alston said following Kar’s release.
I assume that he meant this positively, but I find it impossibly difficult to interpret it as such. If this is a great example, how horrendous are the “not-so-great examples” ?
I’m highly suspicious of military (and executive) leaders who attempt to spin something as horrible as this into a testimonial.
Keep reading, keep (or start) writing, and draw from a diverse group of sources. For America.
In other words, “be vigilant.”